The First Amendment opens with sixteen words about religion: "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof." It sounds tidy, like two halves of one idea. In practice, the Founders gave us two roommates who share a studio apartment and can't stand each other. The Establishment Clause says the government must keep its hands off religion. The Free Exercise Clause says the government must not make life hard for religion. Push either one far enough and it runs straight into the other. Chief Justice Warren Burger admitted as much in 1970, when he wrote that both clauses are "cast in absolute terms, and either of which, if expanded to a logical extreme, would tend to clash with the other". [Burger] He argued that rigid, absolutist interpretations of either clause would undermine their shared constitutional goal of ensuring that the government neither sponsors nor inhibits religion. That was a rare moment of judicial candor, like a marriage counselor conceding the couple might just be incompatible.
The Supreme Court has spent roughly eighty years acting as their landlord, and each new tenant on the bench rearranges the furniture. In 1947, Everson v. Board of Education [Everson] borrowed Jefferson's "wall of separation," a phrase from his 1802 letter to the Danbury Baptists, and the wall quickly turned into the nation's favorite construction project. In 1971 came the Lemon test, a three-part checklist so loved that justices spent decades mocking it. Scalia compared it to a ghoul in a late-night horror movie that keeps rising from the grave. Then in 1990, Scalia himself held in Employment Division v. Smith [Smith] that two men fired for using peyote in Native American Church ceremonies had no constitutional complaint against a neutral, generally applicable drug law. Congress was horrified enough to pass the Religious Freedom Restoration Act almost unanimously in 1993. The Court answered in 1997 by ruling that the law couldn't be applied to the states. Everyone was offended in turn, which may be the closest thing to balance this area of law has ever reached.
Lately the pendulum has swung hard toward free exercise. In Kennedy v. Bremerton (2022),[Kennedy] the Court sided with a football coach who prayed at the 50-yard line and announced that Lemon had been "long ago abandoned," which was news to the lower courts that had been dutifully applying it. Cases like Espinoza and Carson v. Makin went further: if a state funds private schools at all, it can't leave out the religious ones. That once would have looked like a textbook establishment problem. Now refusing the money looks like the textbook free exercise problem. The Court likes to say there is "play in the joints" between the two clauses. That's lawyerly language for admitting the hinges have squeaked since 1791 and nobody has found the oil can.
The Lemon test was at least easy to remember. Under Lemon v. Kurtzman (1971),[Lemon] a law touching religion had to pass three checks: it needed a secular purpose, its main effect could neither advance nor inhibit religion, and it couldn't cause "excessive entanglement" between church and state. It was a smoke detector set so sensitive that a lit birthday candle set it off. In 1980, Stone v. Graham [Stone] used that kind of reasoning to strike down a Kentucky law posting the Ten Commandments in classrooms, since nobody believed the purpose was secular. Lemon also covered only the Establishment Clause. Free exercise cases ran on a separate track, and after Smith that track mostly said neutral laws win and believers lose. So the old arrangement was strict about government embracing religion and fairly relaxed about government stepping on it. Separationists liked that setup. Religious conservatives felt they were losing on both fronts.
The current Court has flipped that arrangement. In place of Lemon's checklist, Kennedy v. Bremerton told courts to look to "historical practices and understandings" and what the Founders understood. In practice, as Erwin Chemerinsky argues at SCOTUSblog, [Chemerinsky] that means probably only outright coercion to worship will count as an establishment. The Fifth Circuit has already applied the history test to uphold Texas's 2025 law putting the Ten Commandments in every classroom, reasoning that the text has picked up a nonreligious meaning over time. That's the same idea Stone rejected, now back after forty-six years. Meanwhile, free exercise keeps getting stronger. In Mahmoud v. Taylor (2025)[Mahmoud], the Court held that parents who couldn't opt their kids out of LGBTQ-themed storybooks had their religious rights burdened. In Catholic Charities Bureau v. Wisconsin (2025)[Catholic], a unanimous Court ruled that drawing lines between religions on theological grounds is a denominational preference that gets the highest scrutiny. In Lemon's era, a state worrying too much about church-state entanglement was being careful. Now it can get the state sued.
The next test is already underway. On November 3, the justices heard St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy, [St. Mary] in which Catholic preschools want money from Colorado's universal pre-K program without signing its nondiscrimination agreement. One question is whether Carson v. Makin [Carson] overrides Smith only when a government explicitly excludes religious groups, or more broadly. A ruling is expected by early summer 2027. CNN notes the Court has never formally overruled Smith but has "effectively sidelined it," which is a polite way of saying it's still employed but nobody gives it any work. Put simply, Lemon asked whether the government had gotten too close to religion. Today's Court mostly asks whether the government has kept religion too far away. The two roommates still share the studio. One of them just got the lease.
The Religion Clauses have always been easiest to see in their oddest cases, and few are odder than the Church of the Lukumi Babalu Aye v. City of Hialeah (1993).[Hialeah] A Santería congregation announced plans to open a church in Hialeah, Florida, where worship would include sacrificing chickens and other animals. The city council quickly passed ordinances banning ritual animal sacrifice. Those ordinances were so carefully drafted that they still allowed hunting, fishing, kosher slaughter, pest control, and frying up a bucket of drumsticks for Sunday dinner. A chicken could die for nearly any reason in Hialeah except a religious one. The Supreme Court ruled unanimously against the city, and Justice Kennedy called the ordinances a "religious gerrymander." Even under Smith's tolerant rule for neutral laws, a law has to be neutral first. Lukumi still serves as the cautionary tale for any town that thinks it can single out one faith while pretending it's only talking about poultry.
Then there's the opposite question: what counts as a religion at all? The Church of the Flying Spaghetti Monster was founded in Kansas in 2005 to protest the state Board of Education's move toward teaching "intelligent design". Pastafarians soon showed up in court. Stephen Cavanaugh, an inmate in Nebraska, sued because prison officials wouldn't let him wear pirate clothing, hold weekly services, or take communion in the form of a large plate of spaghetti and meatballs. In Cavanaugh v. Bartelt (2016),[Cavanaugh] Judge John Gerrard ruled that FSMism is "a parody" and not a religion. He added that reading its gospel as doctrine "would be little different from grounding a 'religious exercise' on any other work of fiction". That leaves judges, who are told never to judge the truth of anyone's faith, deciding which faiths are real enough to protect. It's an uncomfortable job, and the colander-wearing petitioners know exactly where that discomfort. I hasten to note that one of the more successful religions wasn't considered one at the beginning. In The Late Corporation of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints v. United States (1890),[Mormon] the U.S. Supreme Court suggested that the Church was not entitled to full constitutional protection because it viewed Mormonism’s practice of plural marriage as outside traditional religious bounds. Could the Catholic Church suffer the same fate for cannibalism ("this is my body... etc.) in a different regime?
That brings us to Texas, where S.B. 10 requires a Ten Commandments poster, at least 16 by 20 inches, in a conspicuous spot in every public school classroom. On April 21, 2026, the full Fifth Circuit upheld the law 9–8. The majority said Stone v. Graham, the 1980 ruling that struck down Kentucky's nearly identical law, died along with Lemon. [Stone]It also found the law shows none of the hallmarks of a founding-era establishment, like compelled worship or religious taxes. In the court's view, the law just "puts a poster on a classroom wall". Families who are Christian, Jewish, Hindu, and nonreligious asked the Supreme Court to step in in August.[Nathan] Notice the pattern across all three stories. Hialeah couldn't single out the chicken sacrificers. The Pastafarians couldn't qualify as a religion in the first place. Texas can put one particular set of commandments over the chalkboard as long as nobody is forced to recite them. It's a fair bet that if a Pastafarian donated a framed poster of the Eight [FSM] "I'd Really Rather You Didn'ts," the principal would suddenly rediscover the Establishment Clause.
[Burger] Walz v. Tax Commission of the City of New York, 397 U.S. 664, 668–69. https://www.oyez.org/cases/1969/135
[Carson] https://www.oyez.org/cases/2021/20-1088
[Cavanaugh] https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/7319733/cavanaugh-v-bartelt/
[Chemerinsky] https://www.scotusblog.com/2026/10/the-supreme-courts-next-major-case-on-the-free-exercise-of-religion/
[Everson] https://www.oyez.org/cases/1940-1955/330us1
[FSM] https://doctorspaghetti.org/our-faith/
[Hialeah] https://www.oyez.org/cases/1992/91-948
[Kennedy] (https://www.scotusblog.com/cases/kennedy-v-bremerton-school-district-2/)
[Lemon] https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/403/602/
[Mahmoud] https://www.scotusblog.com/cases/mahmoud-v-taylor/
[Mormon] https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/136/1/
[Nathan] https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/ca5/25-50695/25-50695-2026-04-21.html and https://www.aclu.org/cases/nathan-v-alamo-heights-independent-school-district
[St. Mary] https://www.scotusblog.com/cases/st-mary-catholic-parish-v-roy/